wh347's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Whitmore the Toad Pirate3]

Yes!

This is seriously 1000X better than FF7 random battles. I loved the music it played when the beaver came in each time. I respect your creativity. Keep up being awesome.

EdibleCastle responds:

dont really know why u're comparing it to that. but thanks!

[Just Another Psycho]

eh, meh

Don't take this review the wrong way, because I think you have an assload of talent in flash, but really, this wasn't a very thought provoking movie. It was very cliche, and it felt very forced. You have serious skill with drawing and animating, but it is going to waste when you make dumb violent shit. I am obviously not the majority here though, seeing as how this is probably going to get #1 of all time, so I guess this lame violence sells. And Korn is really pretty bad. There is a lot of good music out there that could establish the same feel.

Evil-Dog responds:

Thanks for the praises.
About the movie, it's not to be taken seriously, it's just a sick and twisted little short and I don't think I "wasted" any talent in it, I just trained my skills a little more. And about your musical tastes it's really subjective.

[Megaman:Titanium Rhapsody]

Less is more!

Less is more in this movie, as it has very little animation and backgrounds. It is incredibly easy to take sprites and a random song and throw a bunch of random shit together, but this movie shows actual coherence and looked like there was some thought put into it. Really good TO THE BEAT action going on too. The one suggestion I have would be to have the playing of the piano and guitar go more along with the song. I can see you tried to do it, but I don't think it looked quite right. Could have been ultra badass. But it obviously didn't bother me that much, because I'm still giving you a ten. Rock on man.

FatSatan responds:

Yeah, the instruments were the last bit I animated, so I kinda cut a few corners there.

[Dr. Shroud in: La Maudite]

The easiest

It is easy for one to write about the bad things in this movie, but first, I want to talk about the good things. The art was amazing. I love the paintbrush with smoothed lines, very nice look. And your coloring was really good. The audio recording was also incredibly clear. But two things really stood out to me in this movie. At the part where it shows him walking up the stairs from the side, his foot goes way to far back. Think about where your feet go when walking up the stairs. And the skewing of the piece of wood as it fell down on the old man. That was just cheap as hell. It was really obvious that you just got lazy. The story was mediocre, but it reminded me quite a bit of Ghostbusters. Anyway, overall, I liked it, and don't take my critisism to seriously if you read this, because I really did like your movie.

robfeldman responds:

"reminded me quite a bit of Ghostbusters"

That was the idea. Thanks for your comments!